Newsletters

700

Tips When Goods Are Damaged or Lost During Transport

Nine things you need to know about claims resulting from transport by truck, as established by the applicable laws and cases. These tips could be helpful whether you are making a claim or defending against one.

  1. The contract of transport binds the parties and constitutes the law which governs them. It is known as a “Bill of Lading” or under the abbreviation “BOL”, also known as a “connaissement” in French. It includes the names of the sender, recipient and carrier, the location and date of the pick-up, points of origin and destination, and a description of the goods, including the quantity, volume or weight.
  2. The carrier has an obligation to transport the property to its destination. It is an obligation of result, from which it can only be released by proving that the damage was caused by a fortuitous event or the inherent defect of the goods.
  3. When a trucking company subcontracts a leg of the transportation to another trucking company, the two companies are jointly and severally liable if a loss occurs: each of them is 100% responsible for the loss and the shipper can file a claim with either or both for the entire amount of the claim.
  4. All claims are subject to an advance written notice to be given to the carrier. This notice must be sent within 60 days from the date of delivery, whether the loss to the property is apparent or not, or nine months from the date of shipment if the property has not reached its destination. Failure to give this notice constitutes a bar for making a claim.
  5. Provided a notice has been duly forwarded to the carrier within the prescribed time frame, a claim is subject to a three-year prescription period from the date the property was or should have been delivered.
  6. If the value of the goods transported is declared on the bill of lading, this value will be the limit of the trucking company’s liability, not only for the damage to the goods, but also for all other consequential damages.
  7. In the absence of a declared value on the bill of lading, the liability of the trucking company is limited to $4.41 per kilo according to a pre-printed clause appearing in most bills of lading.
  8. If liability is limited to $4.41 per kilo, in virtue of such a clause the limit will be set by taking into consideration the total weight of the shipment, even if the loss is only partial. This value represents the trucking company’s maximum liability for all damage, including consequential damages.
  9. A trucking company is not liable for the loss of high-value goods if it carries these goods without knowing their value.

The above are general recommendations. Many factors, such as the mode of transportation or a foreign origin or destination could dictate the application of different rules. Do not hesitate to contact one of our team members for more information.

700

Authors

Normand Laurendeau

Lawyer, Partner

Articles in the same category

Bill 56 — Family Law Reform and Parental Union Regime

The National Assembly of Quebec has adopted Bill 56 entitled An Act respecting family law reform and establishing the parental union regime, which will come into force on June 30, 2025. This initiative will introduce the parental union regime which will apply to de facto spouses that will become parents of the same child after […]

When Water Rules Out Any Possibility of Compensation

The Superior Court recently ruled on the interpretation of an exclusion clause for damages resulting from a flood, in Gestion Michel Bernard inc. v. Promutuel Chaudière-Appalaches, Société mutuelle d’assurance générale[1]. Summary of the Facts The Plaintiffs are the owners of a building located in Beauceville and the operators of a restaurant located in that building. […]

Estate Planning: Don’t Overlook Your Safe Deposit Box

Whether you have an estate plan in place or are in the process of estate planning or you have procrastinated about estate planning, you may wish to consider the pros and cons of a safe deposit box (also commonly called a safety deposit box) in your estate plan. At one time, safe deposit boxes were […]

The Duty to Inform in a Commercial Transaction

“The [person drafting] the documents for a transaction has a duty to inform the co-contracting parties of any changes he makes to these documents.’’ [1] – this is how the Honourable Ian Demers, J.C.S., began his judgment dated April 23, 2024, in Maçons Patrimoniaux Inc. v. Aliston Investissement Inc., 2024 QCCS 1447. In this case, […]

Medical Certificates and Bill C-68: What Are the Consequences for Employers?

Scope of Application and Entry into Force The Act mainly to reduce the administrative burden of physicians (“Bill 29”) was passed on October 8, 2024. These provisions amend the Act respecting labour standards (the “ALS”) and will come into force on January 1, 2025. These new prohibitions also apply to employees governed by the Act […]

A Heritage Building, Arson and Deadly Fire: Was the 15 Day Notice to the City Required?

Facts On March 16, 2023, a fatal fire destroyed a heritage building in Old Montréal owned by Plaintiff Mr. Émile Benamor. It is alleged that the fire was caused by a third party and was of a criminal nature. The plaintiff brought an action against the City of Montréal claiming $7 575 000, for the […]