Bulletins

194

Enforcement in Quebec of Foreign Judgments: Restraint Is in Order With Abusive Clauses

Quebec law allows for the recognition and enforcement of judgments rendered by foreign courts. Although these decisions are rendered according to foreign laws, can or must Quebec courts take into consideration the Quebec and Canadian public order principles in deciding whether to recognize such judgments?

In Awanda c. AMBC Ventures Inc., 2022 QCCA 1133, the Court of Appeal had the opportunity to answer this question.

The Superior Court had accepted to partially recognize and enforce a British judgment ordering the repayment of a US$100,000 loan with an annual basic effective interest rate of 438%, to which an extra 73% was added in case of contractual default. The amount owing under the judgment reached a total of US$536,500.

However, considering that a high interest rate was contrary to public order, the trial judge used his discretionary power to reduce the interest rate to 60%, the maximum allowable interest rate under section 347 of the Canadian Criminal Code.

On August 19, the Court of Appeal ruled that the British judgment was in part incompatible with public order within the meaning of paragraph 5 of article 3155 of the Civil Code of Québec.

The Court of Appeal, basing itself on article 3159 of the Civil Code, amended the decision of the trial court and recognized only the part of the British judgment relating to the reimbursement of capital. The court highlighted that Quebec courts may not amend the conclusions of a foreign judgment.

In the end, only the legal interest rate of 8% and some applicable judicial costs, included in the British judgment, were recognized, for a total of CA$218,356.89.

194

Authors

Articles in the same category

Crisis averted on the Canal!

With unpredictable weather at an all-time high, cities and municipalities are facing increased claims resulting from pedestrian falls. Even on sunny days, cities are not immune from potential risks, as was the case in a recent decision rendered by the Court of Quebec in Unlusoy v. Ville de Sainte-Anne-de-Bellevue 2022 QCCQ 9681. As highlighted by […]

Dangerous “fish and chips”

This culinary specialty of British origin was the focus of a decision of the Superior Court (McKnight v. Promutuel Assurances Boréale, 2020 QCCS 71) confirmed just before Christmas 2022 by the Court of Appeal (Promutuel Assurance Boréale v. McKnight, 2022 QCCA 1735). This decision is interesting with respect to two aspects that we have previously […]

An “Owner Occupant” Home Insurance Requires Actual Occupancy by the Owner

On December 20, 2022, in Dang c. Industrielle-Alliance, assurance auto et habitation inc., 2022 QCCA 1739, the Court of Appeal maintained the Superior Court judgment which was the topic of our bulletin of June 17, 2021 (Homeowner Insurance Policy: The Importance of Living in the Insured Dwelling). The Superior Court Decision Appellant was the sole […]

Assumption of Risks in Sports: Two Recent Superior Court Decisions

There is a theory in civil liability called “assumption of risk”. This well-enshrined notion is based on the premise that an individual who willingly participates in a risky or dangerous activity and is aware of the inherent risks associated thereto cannot claim damages if he is injured when this risk or danger materializes. Two recent […]

Overview of the New Provisions of the Act Respecting the Protection of Personal Information in the Private Sector — What are the Implications for Employers?

The Act to modernize legislative provisions as regards the protection of personal information, SQ 2021, c. 25, amending the Act respecting the protection of personal information in the private sector, CQLR c P-39.1 [Act], among others, was proclaimed in force on September 22, 2021. Several provisions came into force on September 22, 2022. The bulk […]

Year-end portrait 2022 — Insurance Law

Profile of Rachel Clément Rachel Clément is a partner, and co-chair of our Insurance Law Group. In addition to conducting her practice and ensuring the group’s leadership, she plays a key role in managing our client relationships, especially with major clients in Quebec and Ontario as well as in London. An active member of the […]

Be the first informed:

Subscribe to our communications