Think of renewing your employment contracts upon expiry!

Three years ago, you hired a sales rep. You drew an employment agreement defining the compensation, working schedule and vacations. Since the rep was to occupy a strategic position in your company, you inserted non-competition and non-solicitation clauses into the agreement. Finally, you stated that the agreement would be limited to a three-year duration, and that its renewal would require an express agreement.

This contract expired last January 29. However, through the hustle and bustle of daily activity, no one paid attention to the fact that the contract had come to an end, and no one was surprised when the rep showed up for work on February 1 and kept doing his job through the week.

It may have been a mere week’s work, but the legal consequences are significant:

  • By application of art. 2090 C.C.Q., the contract was tacitly renewed for an indeterminate term since the employee continued to carry on his work for five days after the expiry of the term, without objection from the employer; and
  • Following a recent judgment (Traffic Tech inc. c. Kennell, 2016 QCCS 355), the renewal only applies to the essential elements of the contract, such as compensation, working hours and vacations: accessory conditions, such as non-competition and non-solicitation clauses, are not renewed.

This consequence can have a very detrimental impact for the employer. Without non-competition and non-solicitation clauses, an employee who resigns would only be bound by a duty of faithfulness and honesty under art. 2088 C.C.Q., a far cry from explicit clauses. Your sales rep could then resign and work for a competitor after giving you a reasonable notice of termination.

How can you protect your rights?

Since you and your employee are bound by a fixed-term contract (a contract with predetermined termination date), you must select one of two avenues:

  • If you wish to keep the employee at your service, you must renew the contract before it expires, under the terms, if any, that you specified in the contract. You may renew the contract for a duration other than that of the original contract. You may also enter into a contract for an indeterminate term. But you must insert into the new contract all the necessary clauses, such as non-competition and non-solicitation clauses.
  • If you no longer need the employee’s services, you must end the relationship as soon as the contract comes to its term by notifying the employee that the contract has expired and that it will not be renewed.

Drafting an employment contract and managing its renewal are operations for which legal advice can avoid many problems. Do not hesitate to consult with a qualified legal advisor before the costly consequences become inevitable.

Commentary by Jacques Bélanger, from our Labour and Employment Law Group.


Articles in the same category

Manufacturers: the heat is on!

An important decision in Product Liability and the obligation of Diligence and Transparency The Court of Appeal recently rendered a decision in CCI Thermal Technologies Inc. c. AXA XL (XL Catlin), 2023 QCCA 231, concerning the liability of the manufacturer and the apportionment of liability between the parties. This case involved twenty separate fires caused […]

Four RSS Lawyers Named Litigation Stars

We’re proud to announce that four of our lawyers were named “Litigation Star” by Benchmark Litigation Canada for 2023: Patrick Henry, Lynne Kassie, Hugues Duguay and Vikki Andrighetti. Congratulations for this accomplishment!

Without a Written Conventional Subrogation, Your Recourse May Be Dismissed

On March 28, 2023, the Superior Court of Quebec partially granted a motion to dismiss the case, dealing with the notions of legal subrogation, conventional subrogation and prejudice. This judgment, Gouvernement de la Nation Crie / Cree Nation Government c. 9327-1781 Québec inc., 2023, reminds us that it is essential for a non-insurer to agree […]

Standard Mortage Endorsment: Is it a Shield for the Creditor?

The scope and protection afforded to a mortgage creditor by the standard mortgage endorsement was again analyzed by the Court of Appeal in Roma Capital inc. 2023 QCCA 307. It should be noted that in this decision rendered on March 7, 2023, the Court of Appeal was hesitant since the decision was rendered on a […]

The strict standard applicable to the exclusion clause for suicide

On February 3, 2023, in Bolduc v. SSQ Assurance, 2023 QCCS 266, the Superior Court once again reminded the insurance industry that strict compliance with the rules governing the drafting of exclusion clauses, particularly in the case of suicide, is essential to avoid unfortunate consequences for insurers. The facts in dispute On November 23, 2006, […]

Where do you keep your corrosive cleaner?

The Facts La Capitale was claiming reimbursement of more than $137,000 in compensation paid to its insureds following water damage that occurred in their home on February 2, 2017. La Capitale was thus suing the general contractor who built the residence in 2012, the distributor of the faucet whose flexible pipe failed, as well as […]

Be the first informed:

Subscribe to our communications