Newsletters

302

The boat disappears: the claim sinks!

Updated on August 2, 2023

Following the dismissal of his appeal by the Quebec Court of Appeal, Mr. Desmeules Beaumont filed an application for leave to appeal to the Supreme Court of Canada.

On June 22, 2023, the Supreme Court of Canada dismissed Mr. Desmeules Beaumont’s application for leave to appeal, thereby confirming the decision of the Quebec Court of Appeal.

***

Was it a theft or was it a fraud?

This was the question the Quebec Court and the Court of Appeal had to answer in the matter of Christian Desmeules Beaumont v. Société d’assurance Beneva inc. (2023 QCCA 50 (2021 QCCQ 7298). An insured (“the insured”) claimed the amount of $38,303 from its insurer who refused to indemnify him following the loss of a boat due to a fraudulent scheme. 

The insured owned a “Runabout Triumph” pleasure boat. In the spring of 2019, he agreed to the terms of a sale with a buyer for a price of $23,000. In the hours leading up to the trade-in, the buyer informed him that he had mandated a trusted carrier to pick up the boat and to pay the insured. A few days later, the situation took a turn for the worse when the bank where the insured had deposited the money informed him that the amount would be withdrawn from his bank account because the bank draft that had been given to him was counterfeit. The insured sought indemnification from his insurer, who denied coverage.

Court of Quebec decision

The issue in this case was whether the insurance policy covered the loss described above.

The Court proceeded to analyze the policy, which covered “all risks directly affecting the insured property, subject to the exclusions and limitations of this contract”. The Court had to determine whether, in these circumstances, the loss of the boat could be considered direct damage to the property covered by the policy.

To do so, the Court based itself on the Court of Appeal decision of Commerce & Industry Insurance Co. of Canada v. Giovanni Management Ltd. and distinguished between the notion of theft and fraud. The difference between these two concepts lies in the victim’s intention to dispose of the property. In the case of theft, the victim will not have voluntarily surrendered the property, unlike in the case of fraud.

In this case, however, the situation was more akin to fraud, since the insured had voluntarily handed over the boat to the buyer in exchange for a sum of money. Although the boat was obtained dishonestly, the fact remains that the boat was voluntarily given to the buyer and that the sale did not include a reservation of ownership until full payment was made.

Consequently, the insured’s loss was not directly related to the boat, but to the sum of money that had been given to him. Thus, the Court concluded that the insurer was justified in denying coverage on the basis that the loss was not directly linked to the insured property.

Court of Appeal Decision

In a brief decision, the Court of Appeal noted that the leading case on this issue is Commerce & Industry Insurance Co. of Canada v. Giovanni Management Ltd. It concluded that the insured had failed to demonstrate that its situation was different from the case before the Court in the above-mentioned decision.

Indeed, according to the Court of Appeal, although said decision was rendered in 1985, the underlying logic derived from it remains valid and still governs the interpretation of the insurance policy at issue. The Court of Appeal therefore confirmed the decision of the Court of Quebec which had dismissed the insured’s action.

302

Articles in the same category

The Pool Floats, the Claim Sinks

In the recent decision Piscines Élégance – Québec inc. v. Comtois, 2023 QCCS 4574, the Superior Court reiterates the rules governing a contractor’s obligation to inform his customer in the context of a fixed-price consumer contract for which hefty extras were billed. Piscines Élégance – Québec Inc. (“Piscines“) is claiming from defendant Comtois (“Comtois“) the […]

Apostille: A Simplified Process for International Legalisation of Documents

On January 11, 2024, a new procedure came into effect for the legalisation of documents issued throughout Canada (including Québec) and which are destined to be produced before foreign authorities, whether they be supporting documents for administrative purposes such as the issuing of permits or full-fledged pieces of evidence used as exhibits in international Court […]

The Defect Was Well Hidden, but Is That Enough?

In Cvesper v. Melatti, the Court of Appeal reminds us of the importance of a timely notice to the vendor in cases of latent defects as tardiness or omission to do so may fatally impact the purchaser’s recourse The Facts Essentially, in May 1980, Appellant, Mrs. Cvesper, purchased a property consisting of a multi-unit building […]

Theft Is Not Negligence

In a recent decision, the Quebec Court of Appeal upheld the ruling of the Honourable Chantal Corriveau of the Superior Court that a party cannot benefit from the presumptions of liability in the Civil Code of Quebec when there is no contractual relation between the parties. In such cases, the rules of extra-contractual liability apply, […]

Company Found Guilty of Criminal Negligence Causes Death to Its Truck Driver

Last August 11, the Quebec Court of Appeal dismissed the appeal and upheld the trial judge’s decision finding CGF Construction Inc. (the “employer”) guilty of criminal negligence causing death1. The victim in question, a truck driver with over 25 years’ experience, died after losing control of the employer’s heavy container truck, which flipped over on […]

The « Appropriate Care » Provision in Disability Insurance: An Application Bearing Heavy Consequences for the Insured

In Desjardins Sécurité financière v. Hébert, the Court of Appeal reminds us of an essential condition often overlooked in order to claim disability insurance benefits: the obligation to be under the care of a medical team and to receive medical treatment, a contextualization of the obligation to mitigate one’s damages. The Court also considers the […]