Newsletters

152

The Warranty Against Latent Defects: The Importance of Presumptions

The Superior Court’s decision in Compagnie d’assurances AIG du Canada c. Kenworth Québec inc., 2020 QCCS 1377, is a reminder of the principles applicable to the warranty against latent defects.

In April 2014, a Kenworth vehicle belonging to the City of Shawinigan [City] and insured by Compagnie d’assurances AIG du Canada [AIG] caught fire and was severely damaged. AIG indemnified its insured and instituted subrogation proceedings against the vendor of the vehicle, Kenworth Québec inc. [Kenworth], invoking the warranty against latent defects. Kenworth in turn filed a claim against the manufacturer, Paccar du Canada ltée [Paccar], also invoking that warranty. AIG filed an expertise report which concluded that most of the damages caused by the fire were in the motor compartment of the vehicle. The expert also underlined that there was a recall by the manufacturer in relation to risks of fire with Kenworth vehicles of the same model but assembled during a period that began a few days after the damaged vehicle was manufactured. Paccar’s expert underlined that the vehicle showed signs of excessive corrosion and that when such vehicle is used in a hostile environment, such as snow removal, particular attention is required to assure that the components of the motor are exempt of salt.

First, the Court underlined the provisions of the Civil Code of Québec governing latent defects affecting goods sold by a professional vendor and stated that this regime creates a presumption of liability when the purchaser establishes that the goods were acquired from a professional vendor or a person who is obliged to such a warranty as a professional vendor, and that the goods deteriorated prematurely in comparison to similar goods. This presumption of liability is triggered without it being necessary to prove the cause of the defect or the cause of the damages. The Court stated that it is a triple presumption of liability, namely:

  1. A presumption of the existence of a defect;
  2. A presumption that the defect existed at the time of the sale;
  3. A presumption of existence of a causal link between the defect and the deterioration of the property.

The presumption may be rebutted if the professional vendor establishes:

  1. Misuse of the property; and
  2. That the improper use is the cause of the premature deterioration or the improper functioning of the property.

After having analyzed the evidence, the Court noted that on the balance of probability, the vehicle had perished because of an electrical problem originating in the motor compartment. Although the Court concluded that the exact point of origin and the cause of the fire had not been established on the balance of probabilities, it underlined that this did not have to be established in a precise manner by the plaintiff in order to trigger the presumption of liability. Since the two conditions for the application of the presumption were satisfied, the causal link between the default and the damage was presumed.

The Court then proceeded to analyze whether the defendants had rebutted the presumption. In order to do so, it had to establish misuse and that the misuse caused the fire. The defendants alleged that the City could have prevented the fire by providing better maintenance for the vehicle. The Court ruled that the City had behaved appropriately by following the procedures dictated in the vehicle owner’s manual.

Accordingly, the Court granted the action and ultimately held Paccar liable.

152

Authors

Mariella De Stefano

Lawyer, Partner and Co-chair of the Insurance Law Group

Articles in the same category

Even Judicial Discretion Has its Limits

On January 25, 2024, in the Liquidation de Groupe Dessau inc., the Superior Court of Québec rejected a settlement approval request in the context of the voluntary liquidation of several entities of the Dessau-Verreault-LVM Group (“Dessau“). This judgment addresses the limits of the discretionary powers of the court in voluntary liquidation matters. Overview of the […]

The Pool Floats, the Claim Sinks

In the recent decision Piscines Élégance – Québec inc. v. Comtois, 2023 QCCS 4574, the Superior Court reiterates the rules governing a contractor’s obligation to inform his customer in the context of a fixed-price consumer contract for which hefty extras were billed. Piscines Élégance – Québec Inc. (“Piscines“) is claiming from defendant Comtois (“Comtois“) the […]

Apostille: A Simplified Process for International Legalisation of Documents

On January 11, 2024, a new procedure came into effect for the legalisation of documents issued throughout Canada (including Québec) and which are destined to be produced before foreign authorities, whether they be supporting documents for administrative purposes such as the issuing of permits or full-fledged pieces of evidence used as exhibits in international Court […]

The Defect Was Well Hidden, but Is That Enough?

In Cvesper v. Melatti, the Court of Appeal reminds us of the importance of a timely notice to the vendor in cases of latent defects as tardiness or omission to do so may fatally impact the purchaser’s recourse The Facts Essentially, in May 1980, Appellant, Mrs. Cvesper, purchased a property consisting of a multi-unit building […]

Theft Is Not Negligence

In a recent decision, the Quebec Court of Appeal upheld the ruling of the Honourable Chantal Corriveau of the Superior Court that a party cannot benefit from the presumptions of liability in the Civil Code of Quebec when there is no contractual relation between the parties. In such cases, the rules of extra-contractual liability apply, […]

Company Found Guilty of Criminal Negligence Causes Death to Its Truck Driver

Last August 11, the Quebec Court of Appeal dismissed the appeal and upheld the trial judge’s decision finding CGF Construction Inc. (the “employer”) guilty of criminal negligence causing death1. The victim in question, a truck driver with over 25 years’ experience, died after losing control of the employer’s heavy container truck, which flipped over on […]