Newsletters

69

The Court of Appeal Considers the Impact of the COVID-19 Crisis on Contractual Relationships

As of April 16, 2020, there have been some 27 published judgements rendered by Quebec courts and tribunals that mention COVID.

One decision is of particular interest as it addresses the impact that COVID-19 could have going forward. In Naimer c. Naimer, 2020 QCCA 567, Justice Geneviève Marcotte of the Court of Appeal ruled on April 8th to grant part of the Respondents’ Application for safeguard order. Respondents sought to force a share purchase agreement. Justice Marcotte held that the financial climate created by the unique COVID-19 crisis favoured ordering that the transaction go forward.

The Respondents argued that the transaction, which included a $5.5 million payment to them from the Appellants, must go forward:

[T]he Appellants’ refusal to close the transaction is affecting [the Respondents’] ability to earn a living and to fulfill their obligations to their employees and suppliers and that this will “most undoubtedly cause their company to go bankrupt because there is a lack of available funding”. This is in addition to the COVID-19 crisis which has delayed the opening of their business to the end of the month.

Appellants countered by arguing that there was no urgency given the COVID-19 crisis had suspended Respondents’ business operations, regardless of whether they received the $5.5 million payment or not.

Justice Marcotte wrote:

The lack of funding of the Respondents’ business as a result of being “indefinitely” deprived of the payment of substantial sums of money while having forgone any further remuneration or salary, combined with the COVID pandemia militates in favour of granting the order rather than the opposite, as the situation can only logically aggravate the financial pressure brought upon the Respondents.

It appears that our courts will, in certain circumstances, consider the financial impact of COVID-19 on businesses.

Should you have any questions regarding how COVID-19 is affecting your business please reach out to any member of our Business Law Group who will be eager to work with you.

69

Authors

Jean-Pierre Sheppard

Lawyer, Partner and Head of the Civil and Commercial Litigation Group

Articles in the same category

Even Judicial Discretion Has its Limits

On January 25, 2024, in the Liquidation de Groupe Dessau inc., the Superior Court of Québec rejected a settlement approval request in the context of the voluntary liquidation of several entities of the Dessau-Verreault-LVM Group (“Dessau“). This judgment addresses the limits of the discretionary powers of the court in voluntary liquidation matters. Overview of the […]

The Pool Floats, the Claim Sinks

In the recent decision Piscines Élégance – Québec inc. v. Comtois, 2023 QCCS 4574, the Superior Court reiterates the rules governing a contractor’s obligation to inform his customer in the context of a fixed-price consumer contract for which hefty extras were billed. Piscines Élégance – Québec Inc. (“Piscines“) is claiming from defendant Comtois (“Comtois“) the […]

Apostille: A Simplified Process for International Legalisation of Documents

On January 11, 2024, a new procedure came into effect for the legalisation of documents issued throughout Canada (including Québec) and which are destined to be produced before foreign authorities, whether they be supporting documents for administrative purposes such as the issuing of permits or full-fledged pieces of evidence used as exhibits in international Court […]

The Defect Was Well Hidden, but Is That Enough?

In Cvesper v. Melatti, the Court of Appeal reminds us of the importance of a timely notice to the vendor in cases of latent defects as tardiness or omission to do so may fatally impact the purchaser’s recourse The Facts Essentially, in May 1980, Appellant, Mrs. Cvesper, purchased a property consisting of a multi-unit building […]

Theft Is Not Negligence

In a recent decision, the Quebec Court of Appeal upheld the ruling of the Honourable Chantal Corriveau of the Superior Court that a party cannot benefit from the presumptions of liability in the Civil Code of Quebec when there is no contractual relation between the parties. In such cases, the rules of extra-contractual liability apply, […]

Company Found Guilty of Criminal Negligence Causes Death to Its Truck Driver

Last August 11, the Quebec Court of Appeal dismissed the appeal and upheld the trial judge’s decision finding CGF Construction Inc. (the “employer”) guilty of criminal negligence causing death1. The victim in question, a truck driver with over 25 years’ experience, died after losing control of the employer’s heavy container truck, which flipped over on […]